"Bad cropping" - In or out?

[BobWeaver]

Hi all,

I'm doing this post from a BlackBerry, so I hope it renders correctly.

My most recent submission (after a brief hiatus) was rejected for "bad cropping". My gut feeling is that the screener wants the shot to be taken out some, but perhaps it could also mean a tighter crop.

http://www.railpictures.net/viewreje...d=692044&key=0

Any ideas/opinions?

Thanks,
Cary

[milwman]

To tight on the right side I think.

[NYSubway18]

I would say it's too tight. I don't think the screeners are big fans of the "in your face" shots.

[Dennis A. Livesey]

Originally Posted by NYSubway18

I would say it's too tight. I don't think the screeners are big fans of the "in your face" shots.

uh-oh. He said "in your face."